Posted August 22, 2013

Give And Go: What could stop five contenders from cracking conference finals?

Ben Golliver, Brooklyn Nets, Chicago Bulls, Give-and-Go, Los Angeles Clippers, New York Knicks, Oklahoma City Thunder, Rob Mahoney
Kevin Durant and Russell Westbrook

Kevin Durant (left) and Russell Westbrook can cover up a lot of the Thunder’s flaws. (Christian Petersen/Getty Images)

Give And Go is a recurring feature in which The Point Forward’s Ben Golliver and Rob Mahoney bat an NBA topic du jour back and forth.

This week: digging into five would-be contenders that finished outside the NBA’s final four in 2013, and what might hold them back in 2014. 

1. With Russell Westbrook back, the Thunder could well be the Western Conference favorites. What could get in the way of their second trip to the NBA Finals in three years?

Ben Golliver: After preaching the Thunder’s gospel for most of last season — I’m still not sure everyone realizes just how amazing their regular season scoring differential was — you won’t find me changing my tune. I would summarize my thoughts on Oklahoma City in this order. One: As good as the Spurs were, they don’t make the Finals if Westbrook is healthy. Two: Kevin Martin was a very valuable, but not irreplaceable, rotation piece. Three: The Thunder’s offense will find a way to be elite as long as Kevin Durant and Westbrook are both available. Four: It’s really a shame that Mikhail Prokhorov doesn’t own this team, because the core is so good that the extravagant extras his limitless bankroll would offer could produce the Heat-killing machine that the basketball world is ready to see.

Oklahoma City has upped its winning percentage every year since Durant’s rookie season, and it’s possible that 2014 finally sees the end of that continual improvement simply because the bar was set high at 60 wins in 2012-13.  Even if that does happen, it’s difficult to envision the Thunder’s taking a meaningful step backward when they return such a large portion of last year’s balanced, deep and athletic unit. Put me in the group that believes only a major injury at an inopportune time in the playoffs will stop them from winning the West.

Rob Mahoney: While the Thunder deserve preference as the West favorite, I hesitate to embroider their logo on a “WESTERN CONFERENCE CHAMPIONS” T-shirt just yet. Losing Martin will hurt. It takes a very particular player to oscillate between acting as an ideal complement to two high-usage superstars and working as a primary creator when asked, but Martin filled that role beautifully for OKC and played a part in most of the team’s top lineups. With him gone, I’m not sure that I’m quite ready to trust Jeremy Lamb and Reggie Jackson to the degree to which coach Scott Brooks will now be required.

MAHONEY: Lamb among young players on the spot in 2013-14

Durant and Westbrook are fantastic, and the team’s core is more than capable enough to solidify the Thunder as a top-flight contender despite Martin’s departure. But there’s just enough reason for doubt to leave the West’s playoff outlook as something of an open question. As many as six teams look to be contenders, and the Thunder appear to be first or second among them in championship viability. But it’s one thing to accept the transition (and downgrade) from James Harden to Martin, and another entirely to assume consistency in the transition from Martin to two shaky young players.


Derrick Rose

Derrick Rose (right) hasn’t played an NBA game since April 2012. (Jesse D. Garrabrant/NBAE via Getty Images)

2. Chicago will likely be a credible contender with Derrick Rose’s return, but what might come to separate the Bulls from a chance to take the Eastern Conference?

Mahoney: Miami is the easy answer here, and the definitive one. Everything that the Bulls accomplish will be measured against the defending champions, and rightly so; obstacles loom no larger than the Heat, who have both improved their roster and their ability to execute their game plan since last meeting a Rose-led Bulls team, in the 2011 conference finals. Chicago still has the potential to trouble Miami in a seven-game series, and to take the conference throne if all goes according to plan. But the actualization of that plan begins with Rose being Rose, a development we can’t quite take for granted, given the length of his absence and the reasoning behind his ever-tentative return timeline.

MAHONEY: Grading the Bulls’ offseason

Both are particularly relevant because the Heat will load up on Rose in a potential postseason matchup, a tactic that worked rather effectively two years ago. If Rose isn’t able to drive and shoot with confidence to beat Miami’s defensive pressure on the perimeter, he’ll have to — at the very least — heighten his awareness as a playmaker. With their pick-and-roll traps in that 2011 series, the Heat held Rose to 35 percent shooting and forced him into 3.8 turnovers per game. Miami’s D has only become that much more ferocious since then.

Rose is capable of beating that first line of defense with smart passing and selective attacking, and it’s quite possible that his initial playoff matchup with the Heat was simply the kind of trial that all young players experience. But he’s yet to put it all together in a way that could help Chicago sustain scoring against such an aggressive, scrambling defense, and for that reason I’ll remain slightly skeptical of the Bulls’ chances to take the conference.

Golliver: So much bandwidth has been spent on Rose injury non-updates and outraged responses to his year-long absence that I dare say many have forgotten just how tremendous the Bulls were when he was on the court. A quick reminder: When Rose played, the Bulls were a combined 94-26 (.783) during the 2010-11 and 2011-12 seasons. Put in simpler terms: Chicago went 68-14 in Rose’s last 82 regular-season games.

Yes, a number of the rotation players have turned over in the interim, including Omer Asik, Ronnie Brewer, Kyle Korver and C.J. Watson, but the emergence of Jimmy Butler and the additions of Marquis Teague and now Mike Dunleavy during Rose’s absence should be taken very seriously. Based on the proven track record of the Tom Thibodeau/Rose/Joakim Noah/Luol Deng/Taj Gibson/Carlos Boozer combination, I would start the Bulls at No. 2 on the East pecking order, behind only the Heat.

That brings us to the question of whether Chicago is positioned to defeat Miami in a seven-game series. The answer would seem to be “yes” rather than “YES!” at least until Rose has proved that he is at or near 100 percent and all of the Bulls’ bigs make it to the playoffs in good shape. The Bulls have their heart, toughness, team-first, defense-first ducks in a row, but they have also always seemed one dynamic perimeter scorer short of cracking Miami’s defense. That elusive piece appears to linger as the two teams get ready for what will be a must-see opening-night showdown.

23 comments
Dreballs
Dreballs

the Nets and Knicks are not title contenders, they are wasting space here

jsteppling
jsteppling

boy golliver is a lot smarter than poor mahoney.


kevin martin was catastrophically bad on defense in the post season. So, no, his loss wont hurt at all. In fact forcing brooks to play Lamb is a huge uptick.

DrewinIndy
DrewinIndy

I had to laugh out loud at the suggestion that Miami and Chicago are the two pillars of the Eastern Conference. BWAHAHA! Let me remind everyone, the only team that has had any measure of success against Miami that's still largely intact is the Indiana Pacers. 2011-2012 Boston Celtics gave them trouble, but they're not together any more. 2010-2011 Chicago Bulls gave them trouble, but guess what? That team's no longer together, either. Indiana returns 100% of the best starting 5 in basketball. Period. Look it up, no other 5 put up consistent +/- numbers like Hibbert, West, George, Lance and Hill. Add to that the upgrades of so many trouble positions on the bench, coupled with the return of swingman Danny Granger and the Pacers downfall from last season (an absolutely ATROCIOUS bench) becomes a benefit. There's Miami at the top, they're the 2 time defending world champs, Indiana next, as they've proven to be an excellent defensive team and should get better offensively (which they were a top 10 offense at the ASB last season), then everyone else. BKN has questions marks (age and coaching, mostly), Chicago has question marks (Rose, health, Boozer, and the Bench Mob). If any two teams are the "pillars" of the East, it's Miami and Indiana. Quit living on past accomplishments.

cdog923
cdog923

This article could have been written in one phrase:

The Miami Heat.

FredFlintsone
FredFlintsone

A Melo led team will never win a title. Guy is no Leborn, Wade or Kobe that's for sure. He just scores a lot of points ,sells a lot of tickets. If he decides to be no 2 somewhere maybe  till then forget it. Didn't work for Denver whose owner was $20M over the cap building team around Melo wont work in NY either.

Ohno
Ohno

i'm tired of you media doush-bags taking shots at the Knicks.  Sure STAT's 20 mil could have been better spent elsewhere, but when no one else was coming to NY.  Were the Knicks going to say no?  STAT's the reason the Knicks are relevant again, and only real Ny Knicks fans know that. His body has let him down, but you @ssholes at SI see fit to keep taking shot sat him because it's the easy thing to do.  Unfortunately, the kicks are handicapped by his contract, but he didn't sign in NY knowing that his body was going to breakdown and let him down.  Screw you guys for not being more sensitive, and I hope you rot in journalism hell for not being more considerate.  The Knicks did the best they could with what they had, and they'll prove you wrong just like they did last year when ESPN and SI had them finishing no better than 5th in the East...BOOK IT.  #nykallday #knickstape

SukeMadiq
SukeMadiq

Rose will get the sniffles and miss 3 months...

ajudki20
ajudki20

@jstepplingHuh? Who cares if Martin was bad on Defense? OKC was one of the best defensive teams with him. Their glaring weakness is no other reliable offensive force beyond Durant and Westbrook. Those two are really good scorers, and on occasion others like Ibaka step up, but as a top contender you can't rely on two real sources of offense even if those sources are potent. Losing Harden was a step down and losing Martin was another. At some point these issues will begin to haunt OKC (if they haven't already).

breakinankles
breakinankles

@DrewinIndy when wade was getting 8 points a game and bosh nothing, it was lebron just like in cleveland putting the team on his back.

f8tz
f8tz

@DrewinIndy Pacers match up well with the heat, this much is true. But a healthy rose who plays even 80% of what his form was will blow the pacers away.

NucLear
NucLear

@DrewinIndy What a pack of nonsense. The Pacers only became an Eastern contender in Rose's absence. Now that he's back, he's going to put the Pacers back exactly where they belong: behind the Chicago Bulls, the best defensive team in the NBA.

utoo
utoo

@FredFlintsone Lebron joined Wade and Bosh. Melo joined broken down Amare. Big difference.

Trevor6
Trevor6

Hahahaha. Were you crying the whole time you wrote that?

JeffreyAzevedo
JeffreyAzevedo

@Ohno Why are you calling him STAT`s he was good in NY for like 40 games...you dont earn a nick name in 40 games if thats the case then we should be calling Jeramy Lynn the TRUTH calling Amar`e stats thats funny Career averages of 20&8 for a power forward who played most of his career with Steve Nash

eddie767
eddie767

@Ohno I have to admit,if no one else will,Knicks fans are great. Now,that when that contract of "Stats" is brought up,the fans act like b%#@^es. You are right his body broke down,but the Knicks should've thought about that but didn't. Now they have no money to keep getting better. Don't blame the outsiders,blame the team.

NucLear
NucLear

@SukeMadiq Sounds like you're afraid of Rose coming back at full strength. Well that's not a surprise - every single NBA team should be afraid of Rose coming back, because he's on a mission to humiliate all of you.

jsteppling
jsteppling

@ajudki20 @jsteppling what do you mean who cares if he is bad on defense??????????????????  What does that remark mean? Defense doesnt matter? Um, he was so freaking bad post season that brooks had to finally take him out  for stretches because he was being abused. Read zach lowe's description of the post season for OKC: Defense ALWAYS matters. And martin cant play it at all, in fact he is among the worst permiter defenders in the NBA.

DrewinIndy
DrewinIndy

@NucLear The Indiana Pacers are the best defensive team in the NBA. Rose's return doesn't make the Bulls significantly better on defense. Roy Hibbert is the best interior defender in the league, and Paul George is a better perimeter defender than anyone on Chicago. There's 82 games to be played and anything can happen, but dismiss the Indiana Pacers at your own peril. 

Trevor6
Trevor6

He's calling him that because it's been his nickname his whole career and its tattooed on his neck. Been that way since he was a high schooler.

GYK86
GYK86

@eddie767 @Ohno I like STAT and really wish he could stay healthy, but the Knicks didn't have a ton of options.  They pretty much *had* to offer him that deal, and while it's not working out now, Amare made an impact.

Remember, sports are a business, and the Knicks had the whole city waiting for a LBJ signing that wasn't happening.  They had little choice but to sign SOMEONE to a max deal as an attempt to revitalize basketball in NYC.  Knicks hadn't made the playoffs in 10 years and were a perennial loser.  


STAT was the start of a brand rebuild and served his purpose.  Knicks have good attendance and the fans are interested again.  Amare helped a lot with that.  Contract isn't helping things now, but it absolutely did a lot to help the franchise.

ajudki20
ajudki20

@jsteppling @ajudki20 Of course Defense always matters. But did OKC lose in the playoffs because their D was not good enough? No. So it isn't a big concern. How are they going to score enough when one their big 2 is having an off night? They needed a slight upgrade to spread scoring and got a downgrade instead. It would be great if that 3rd option was a great two way player, but they need another scorer, not another defender. Guys that do both well are rare. You seem to dislike Martin which is fine. He certainly isn't god's gift to defense. But he helped that team get where it needed to. Obviously the team was not designed to be without Westbrook.