Posted October 08, 2013

Ready to shine? Assessing early favorites for first All-Star appearances in 2014

2014 All-Star Weekend, Al Jefferson, Anthony Davis, Ben Golliver, Damian Lillard, DeMarcus Cousins, John Wall, Josh Smith, Kawhi Leonard, Larry Sanders, Paul Millsap, Rudy Gay, Serge Ibaka, Stephen Curry
John Wall

John Wall had the sixth-best Player Efficiency Rating among point guards last year. (Ned Dishman/NBAE via Getty Images)

While there have been about five first-time All-Stars per year since 2005, the 2013 All-Star Game in Houston featured a bunch of new blood, thanks to a rash of injuries to big-name players. All told, there were seven newcomers once Brook Lopez was named as the injury replacement for Rajon Rondo; Brooklyn’s center joined Tyson Chandler, Paul George, James Harden, Jrue Holiday, Kyrie Irving and Joakim Noah, who were all tabbed as reserves by the coaches.

Rondo is still without a definitive timetable for his return (as is 2012 All-Star starter Andrew Bynum), but four players who were sidelined or limited before the break in 2013 — Derrick Rose, Kevin Love, Dirk Nowitzki and Deron Williams — are back in the mix for 2014. Even with Russell Westbrook expected to miss the first 20 games or so, the (very early) forecast for 2014 looks like a tight squeeze on spots available to newcomers.

Indeed, nine of the 10 starting spots, which are determined by a fan vote, already look to be formalities: Rose, Dwyane Wade, LeBron James and Carmelo Anthony in the East, and Chris Paul, Kobe Bryant, Kevin Durant, Blake Griffin and Dwight Howard in the West. That’s true despite Bryant’s indefinite absence due to an Achilles injury, as the fan voting margins have been overwhelming in recent years. A solid number of 2013 reserves for both conferences — including Irving, George, Tony Parker and Harden — are positioned to get the call again for New Orleans, as are 2012 selections like Roy Hibbert and Marc Gasol, who missed the cut in 2013.

If injuries dictated first-time All-Star opportunities in 2013, look for player movement to be the headlining criterion in 2014. Three of last year’s All-Stars changed teams this summer — Howard, Kevin Garnett and Holiday — as did a host of perennial fringe candidates, including Josh Smith, Paul Millsap and Al Jefferson.

The concentration of those moves — particularly the free-agency signings of Smith, Millsap and Jefferson — suggests that the bulk of this year’s first-timers will again come from the Eastern Conference. Holiday’s trade from the Sixers to the Pelicans opens a spot on the East roster, and it further crowds an overcrowded Western Conference backcourt picture. Rudy Gay’s midseason trade from the Grizzlies to the Raptors means that he’s now competing with the likes of Luol Deng and Paul Pierce rather than Love, LaMarcus Aldridge, David Lee and former teammates Gasol and Zach Randolph to earn a spot. The Nets’ blockbuster summer trade consolidated the talent pool in the Atlantic Division, giving Brooklyn the ability to roll out a starting five composed entirely of 2012 and 2013 All-Stars: Williams, Joe Johnson, Pierce, Garnett and Lopez. Still, it would take a very strong start to the season for more than two of those players to be selected in 2014, as the coaches tend to spread the love around.

MAHONEY: NBA’s off-the-court youth movement

Contrast that with the West, where you could construct a potential roster — Paul, Bryant, Durant, Griffin, Howard, Harden, Parker, Westbrook, Tim Duncan, Love, Stephen Curry (in place of Lee) and Gasol (in place of Randolph) — with only one first-timer (Curry), while snubbing the likes of Aldridge, Lee, Randolph, Nowitzki and Holiday, plus all of the other newcomer candidates. Now that’s a deep pool.

Even if the West is likely to feature mostly familiar faces, here’s a quick survey of the top candidates to become first-time All-Stars in 2014 from both conferences.

Eastern Conference

John Wall, Wizards: If the Nets’ Williams doesn’t reclaim his spot after Holiday’s move to the West, Wall looks like the odds-on favorite. After missing the first two-plus months to open the 2012-13 season with a knee injury, Wall came back to average 18.5 points and 7.6 assists while posting a 20.9 Player Efficiency Rating (PER), which ranked No. 6 among point guards. Those individual numbers — in conjunction with Washington’s 24-25 record when he played — helped Wall secure a five-year rookie extension from Washington this summer. Wall’s talent should be enough to keep the Wizards firmly in the playoff picture all season after a five-year postseason drought. That should put some pressure on the coaches to acknowledge Washington’s improvement with their midseason voting. Honestly, who doesn’t want to see the hyper-talented and freakishly athletic Wall in an All-Star setting?

Josh Smith, Pistons: The variables working against Smith’s selection are slowly deteriorating. In Atlanta, he was passed over year after year in favor of his teammates (Johnson, Al Horford) and, it seemed, because he was regarded as a bit of a malcontent. The Hawks’ consistent “good but not great” postseason work created a certain malaise. Moving to Detroit as a free agent gives Smith a fresh beginning, and it could jump-start his All-Star chances.

The Pistons haven’t made the playoffs since 2009 and they are positioned to compete for a spot this season. If things progress as expected, Smith will be in line for the lion’s share of the credit, as he’s the roster’s “biggest name” and most established veteran star type, and he’s produced at an All-Star level for seven straight seasons. His impact will also be easy to gauge: Last season, Atlanta ranked No. 10 in defense while Detroit ranked No. 23. That gap should narrow, perhaps considerably, and a strong swing would make a compelling case for Smith’s value. Deng would seem to be a particularly vulnerable incumbent.

MAHONEY: Potential trade targets in 2013-14

Al Jefferson, Bobcats: Don’t look now, but the East’s crop of All-Star-caliber centers has gotten pretty strong. Even though the NBA relaxed its rules last season, encouraging fans to vote for three “frontcourt” players rather than two forwards and a center, there’s no lack of available talent: Lopez, Hibbert, Noah and Chandler are all contenders for All-Star returns; those four players have established reputations and should produce strong statistical cases while playing for upper-echelon teams. That doesn’t leave much room for Jefferson, whose lowly Bobcats will likely be among the league’s worst teams this season. Still, anything short of 20/10 production from Jefferson would be a categorical disappointment, and those type of numbers get you into the conversation, especially if some of the more traditional selections falter.

Rudy Gay, Raptors: Like Smith, Gay benefits from an increased profile on his new squad. The Raptors haven’t made it to the postseason since 2008, and someone will get some love if they can hang in contention into January. Clearly the No. 1 guy in Toronto (at least until Jonas Valanciunas fully blooms), Gay is also in position to be one of the league’s top 10 scorers, and nine of the top 10 scorers last season earned All-Star nods (Curry was the only exception). Hopefully, the coaches will only reward Gay if his efficiency numbers take a big leap forward, but he’s lurking if Toronto starts well and someone like George unexpectedly falters.

Paul Millsap, Hawks: A regular victim of the Western Conference’s power forward glut, Millsap’s outlook has improved somewhat with his move to Atlanta. He still faces some pretty serious hurdles, namely the presence of Horford and Atlanta’s ingrained reputation as a slightly above-average squad. It doesn’t help that Millsap’s game trends toward workmanlike rather than highlight-driven, or that Smith, one of his top rivals for All-Star recognition, seemingly has a leg up on him when it comes to circumstantial factors. At the very least, though, Millsap should enjoy a little more buzz, as he’s not trying to stand out from the likes of Griffin, Duncan, Randolph, Nowitzki, Aldridge and Lee. That’s an easy forest to get lost in.

GOLLIVER: Position battles in training camp

Larry Sanders, Bucks: The All-Star Game isn’t always the best place to find defense-first big men: Chandler needed 12 seasons to get his first call, while 2013 Defensive Player of the Year Gasol didn’t make the cut for Houston. Throw in the fact that Sanders plays for the small-market Bucks, who are expected to be in the middle of the pack again, and it’s probably best to categorize his chances as a long shot. That said, Milwaukee clearly understands his value, as evidenced by his big-dollar extension this summer, and Sanders, who is just 24, should be in the discussion as a possible All-Star candidate for years to come. His competition as he progresses — Lopez, Hibbert, Noah and Horford — is as clear as can be.


In the Larry Sanders paragraph, you say that DPOY Gasol didn't make the cut for Houston.  He played for Memphis.  Just a heads up.