Posted November 06, 2013

With Tyson Chandler out 4-6 weeks, Knicks face litany of problems

New York Knicks, Rob Mahoney, Tyson Chandler
Tyson Chandler left the game on Tuesday night after colliding with Charlotte's Kemba Walker. (Elsa/Getty Images)

Tyson Chandler left the game on Tuesday night after colliding with Charlotte’s Kemba Walker. (Elsa/Getty Images)

Brutal news for a Knicks team that had been holding its own defensively this season: According to the team (via Ian Begley of ESPN New York), Tyson Chandler, the rim protector at the core of New York’s defensive structure, will miss 4-6 weeks after suffering a non-displaced fracture in his right fibula. The injury will not require surgery.

Chandler was injured during a loss to Charlotte on Tuesday, when the Bobcats’ Kemba Walker barreled down the lane and into his leg. The Knicks center immediately went to the floor and grimaced in pain as he tried to collect himself. Chandler was helped off the court without putting weight on his right leg and did not return.

This puts New York in a miserable spot. Its only effective big man and most crucial defender could now miss up to 21 games, according to the initial timetable. In Chandler’s place, the Knicks will have little choice and much dismay in depending on Andrea Bargnani, Amar’e Stoudemire (who is still under a heavy minutes restriction, and logged just 10 on Tuesday), Kenyon Martin and Cole Aldrich to fill the void. That group should inspire no confidence; none among them has proved capable of consistent play of late, be it due to injury (Stoudemire), age (Martin), inexperience (Aldrich) or more general misery (Bargnani). Getting by without one of the team’s best players would be challenging enough under any circumstances, but doing so with such underwhelming replacement options could well be impossible.

SI.com’s NBA Power Players of 2014

All of which leaves Knicks coach Mike Woodson to sort out a rotation without sufficient remedy. Woodson has his general preference for bigger, more traditional lineups fairly clear, but his coaching calculus has to — and undoubtedly will – change with Chandler sidelined. At this point, running big would be a conscious, regrettable choice made with regard for style over substance. Even in trotting out taller players, New York’s ability to defend the rim is compromised. In four games, the Knicks have allowed opponents to shoot 59.1 percent in the restricted area with Chandler out of the lineup compared to 50.8 percent with him on the floor. Their team rebounding has collapsed when Chandler checks out of the game, too, and this time he’ll remain checked out for weeks. What, then — if not defense, if not rebounding and surely not scoring — would be the intended value of playing big in Chandler’s absence?

That leaves a return to small ball as the best option by default, though even that lineup orientation now suffers from similar issues. Really, none of New York’s flaws are unique to one approach or the other once Chandler is ruled out. The lack of competent rebounders and defenders will be problematic no matter Woodson’s lineups, though perhaps the Knicks can mitigate some of those concerns by best enabling their offense with more talented shooters and creators. As long as Bargnani and Stoudemire continue to be marginal offensive contributors at best (and legitimate hindrances, at worst), the best means of accomplishing that goal lie in going a bit smaller. That such a shift would trim the total number of minutes drawn from New York’s lackluster bigs — as a result of Carmelo Anthony (and, to a lesser extent, Metta World Peace) filling in more often at power forward — is a benefit in itself.

Martin is likely the best fit as a frontcourt counterpart for Anthony, though he won’t likely start and is already paying the physical price for logging a mere 18 minutes Tuesday. Even then, Martin is 35 years old, he’s a middling rebounder and he creates a drag on New York’s offense. That the best option is burdened with limitation speaks volumes about the alternatives. Playing either Bargnani or Stoudemire as a standalone interior defender (with Anthony so lacking in that regard) would (and sadly, will) be an unmitigated disaster, to say nothing of their compounding troubles on the glass and lack of scoring. Neither can be counted on in the slightest — not even for their supposed strengths.

These are the problems that the Knicks now face. Chandler was positioned to be a rock on a team already looking for answers, but without him New York comes untethered. Its small-ball units suffer. Its bigger lineups wither. Its flaws become glaring weaknesses, and its entire playing rotation has now been put in question. Moves could be made, yet the Knicks are without many attractive trade pieces and lacking in the ability to spend any more recklessly than they already have. The fall, from here, is inevitable.

9 comments
SukeMadiq
SukeMadiq

Bargnani will step in and haul down 2 or 3 rebounds a night....

K.r.Qunynghamm
K.r.Qunynghamm

Well, we had no low post game to begin with so not having any low post defense evens things out. Wish Dolan would just sell the team to some folks who know basketball and keep Zeek away from the building. Ok, let's just put Kenyon out there, as he at least knows how to rebound. Stoud may as well go on vacation for the remainder of the season or just sit out until it gets near playoff's time ,and if the Knicks aren't 15 games out, then he can come back and see if he's anything left besides the desire to punch fire extinguishers

WilyCoyoteSuperGenius
WilyCoyoteSuperGenius

While I am sorry to see anyone suffer a serious injury I cannot help but delight in the continuing woes of any Dolan owned team. Father and son are class A jerks and have long stuck it to New Yorkers. It is too sweet to watch the Knicks be overtaken as New Yorks team by the Nets.


train805
train805

Its cuz he skipped so many leg days at the gym! (Remember the pic from earlier this year) haha.

But seriously, that sucks. Hes a good dude.

kj4027
kj4027

Who will Dolan take it out on now? The concession people? Court side waitstaff? Or is it still the dancer's fault that the Knicks, under Dolan, suck again. Last year was an aberration.

geewhiz
geewhiz

Not that the knicks really had a shot this year but...ya stick a fork in em.  

NoQNoSuperBowl
NoQNoSuperBowl

Dolan won't be happy until his buddy Isaiah is back on the bench.

M20
M20

But... but James Dolan said the Knicks have the talent to win a championship now!